Why Your First Consultation Feels Like a Debate Instead of a Diagnosis

Your prospective patient arrives with questions you may not be aware of.

By Jeff Rothbeind

You've finally got them on the phone.


They found your practice through Google, a referral, or perhaps an ad. They've taken the time to schedule a consultation, so you might reasonably expect that the hardest part is over.


But then the questions start...


  • Why does Functional Medicine cost so much?
  • Will this actually work?
  • Is this really different from what they've already tried?
  • Why isn't their insurance going to cover it?


And, sometimes, there's an even more fundamental question underneath all of those:


"Can I trust this?"


Instead of getting right into the patient's history and what brought them to you, you find yourself explaining and defending your approach. You're answering objections that have very little to do with the person sitting in front of you.


It's frustrating, particularly because that's not why you became a Functional Medicine practitioner in the first place.


You want to help people.


You don't want to spend the first part of every consultation convincing them that you're legitimate.

But here's the interesting part...

The defensiveness may not have started during the consultation.

It may have started much earlier, when that person first visited your website.

Your patients don't arrive at your website without questions.

They've probably been dealing with their problem for a while. Many have already seen other practitioners, tried treatments that didn't work, or spent considerable time searching for an explanation.


So when they find your practice, they're not simply looking for information.


They're trying to decide whether they can trust you.


They may be wondering whether what they're experiencing is real, whether you understand their particular problem, and whether there is actually any reason to believe things could get better.


They may also be wondering what it will cost, what will happen if they reach out, and whether they're going to be pressured into something they aren't ready for.


Most won't sit down and write those questions out, but that doesn't mean they're not thinking about them.


And if your website doesn't help answer them, the questions don't simply disappear.


They come with the patient into your consultation.

What if your website could answer those questions first?

Imagine a prospective patient arriving at your website and finding something very different from the usual practice brochure.


Instead of simply telling them what you do, the experience helps them understand that you've seen people like them before. It gives them a clearer sense of what might be happening, what working with you looks like, and what they can expect if they decide to take the next step.


More importantly, it begins to change how they feel.


They may come to understand that their symptoms aren't something they simply have to live with. They may begin to believe that there is a possible path forward. They may feel that someone finally understands what they've been experiencing.


And because you've answered many of the questions that were creating uncertainty, they don't have to arrive at the consultation ready to defend themselves, or make you defend yourself.


They're simply more prepared to have a conversation.

That's a very different starting point.

Instead of beginning with a skeptical prospect who needs to be convinced, you can begin with someone who already has some understanding of your approach and some confidence that you might be able to help.


You can talk about their health history.


You can listen to what they've tried.


You can explore what's happening now and whether your approach is appropriate for them.


The consultation becomes what it was supposed to be in the first place: a conversation about the patient.


Not a defense of the practice.



And your website hasn't replaced that conversation. It has simply done some of the work that needed to happen before it.

Your website has a bigger job than you think.

It's not just an online brochure, and it isn't simply a place to list your services, credentials, and conditions treated.


It's the first experience many prospective patients will have with your practice.


That experience can leave them feeling more confused and uncertain than when they arrived. Or it can begin to give them something they may have been looking for for a very long time:

hope.


That's the idea behind The New Patient Experience.


It's a different way of thinking about what your website should accomplish before a prospective patient ever speaks with you.


Because the goal isn't simply to get someone to book a consultation.


It's to help them feel ready to have one.

free ARTICLE - No opt in required